Did the right two go home? Kady, definitely. Asia'H? First is not an easy time to go, especially if you're going to do a second-rate Whitney routine and then say you're happy being a second-rate Whitney and content with coming in tenth.
Brooke's interpretation of "Love Is A Battlefield" was my favorite of the night. I think the judges way overpraised Amanda's "I Hate Myself For Loving You." The vocals were good but she looked like she was thinking about something else the whole time. Syesha chose the wrong song. Ramiele did okay, but had the misfortune of picking a Phil Collins song the same week David A. did. I still thinking Kristie's forgettable. Carly was second-best of the night. Powerful voice.
On the guys's side, happy to see Luke and Danny gone.